Saltwater Marketing
How to Maximize OTAs & Booking Sites Without Discounting

How to Maximize OTAs & Booking Sites Without Discounting

Monday, 16 November 2026

When guests compare trips on a booking site, price is the first thing they look at. On the TripShock marketplace, 30% of searches go straight to the price filter, and that share has inched up every year.

That doesn't mean the cheapest trip wins. It means you need to know exactly how your price compares, and how to win that comparison without racing to the bottom.

Greg Fisher, CEO of WaveRez booking software and the TripShock marketplace, walked charter and tour operators through the pricing audit he runs with his own operators, with Andre' Savoie of Saltwater Marketing. Here's the full playbook.

How Guests Compare Trips on Booking Sites

Guests on OTAs and booking sites shop in a predictable order:

  1. Price. They filter or sort by price first.

  2. Rating and position. Once a price fits their budget, they look at star ratings, review counts and where you show up in the results.

  3. Everything else. Duration, inclusions and policies come last, if guests get to them at all.

Budget experiences have gained ground this year, according to Viator's CEO at a recent industry event, and WaveRez and TripShock booking data shows the same trend.

Meanwhile, many operators set prices by gut feel. A competitor charges $100, so you charge $98. Your trip runs two hours instead of 90 minutes, so you add $15. But guests see the price before they see the duration. A shorter trip at a lower price often outsells a longer, better trip that costs a little more.

What Guests Actually Compare

When you size up your competitors, these are the data points that matter:

  • Listed price: the number guests see in the search results

  • All-in price at checkout: the total after fees and taxes

  • Duration: how long the trip runs

  • Group size: private or shared, and how many guests the price covers

  • Inclusions: drinks, gear, photos

  • Add-ons and upsells

  • Deposit and cancellation policy: flexibility is a big reason guests book right now

  • Review rating and count

  • Availability: what's open and what's sold out

A $300 private trip can look expensive next to a $60 shared seat until you see it covers six or ten guests. Guests rarely do that math, so you have to make the value obvious.

Step 1: Pick Your Comp Set

Choose the 5 to 8 competitors closest to what you offer. Match the trip type, price range, group size and value. If you run private charters, compare yourself to private charters, not a 50-passenger boat selling seats.

In a crowded market like Destin, with close to 300 fishing charters, don't try to track everyone. Pick the established operators closest to you. The better the fit, the more useful your audit.

Step 2: Shop Like a Guest

Pick the same date and time for every competitor and go all the way to checkout. Note the listed price, the final price and everything that's included.

Watch out for prices that change by channel. One OTA might show a trip at $50 and another at $40, often because the operator added a few dollars to cover a commission. Some OTAs also hide the operator's name, which makes listings hard to match.

The competitor's own booking page is your source of truth. If OTA prices are all over the place in your market, leave them out of the audit.

Step 3: Compare the All-In Price

Many operators hook guests with a low display price, then add fees at checkout. A trip listed at $49 can end up costing more than one listed at $65 once fees and taxes are added.

How well that hook works depends on what you sell. For commodity products, like basic boat rentals or seats on shared tours in crowded markets, a low starting price makes a big difference. For premium, private and luxury trips, guests care more about reviews and the experience.

All-in pricing is spreading. Some states already require it, and some OTAs, like GetYourGuide, show the full price from the start and require it to match your website. Greg's advice: show what your market shows. If your competitors list pre-tax prices and you're the only one showing all-in, you'll look more expensive at a glance, and most guests won't dig deeper to see why.

Step 4: Build Your Positioning Map

Plot every competitor on two scales: price and value. Each one lands in one of four spots:

Lower value

Higher value

Higher price

Overpriced

Premium

Lower price

Race to the bottom

Value leader

Premium and value leader are the strong spots. The race to the bottom is where nobody wants to be. If a competitor lives there, take them out of your comp set: you're not competing with them.

The map shows you where you stand and which lever to pull next.

Let AI Do the Legwork

You don't have to build this by hand. Give Claude or ChatGPT your comp set and their booking page links, and ask it to pull each competitor's prices, durations and inclusions into a table, convert everything to an all-in price, and plot the positioning map.

Then make it automatic. Both tools can run scheduled tasks and email you the results. Set up a weekly report, and you'll know when a competitor drops their rate by $10 or adds a free photo package without logging in to check.

The 5 Levers to Win Without Discounting

Once you know where you stand, cutting your price is the last move, not the first. Here are five levers to pull instead.

1. Make your pricing dynamic. One price all season leaves money on the table. Try lower weekday rates and higher Saturday rates. In a market like Destin, summer isn't one season: it's five or six mini-seasons, from early June through the peak weeks. Price each one.

2. Put your value in the trip title. Guests scanning a booking site don't read descriptions. If your trip includes free drinks and photos and your competitor's doesn't, at the same price, that has to show in the title or the main photo. "Dolphin Cruise" says nothing. "2-Hour Dolphin Cruise with Free Drinks & Photos" wins the side-by-side comparison. As more guests plan trips with AI tools that read your full description, strong descriptions will pay off too.

3. Add value instead of cutting price. If a competitor includes photos and you don't, add a photo package before you drop your rate. Other ideas: an extra 30 minutes on a rental, priority boarding, or a cooler with ice. Get your crew involved, and make sure the extra shows up in your title and short description.

4. Keep your reviews fresh. Competing with an operator who has thousands of reviews can feel impossible. But recent reviews now matter more than total reviews, especially to AI tools. When Greg asked an AI tool about WaveRez, it pointed out that nobody had left a review in eight months.

To keep reviews coming:

  • Automate a post-trip text. Texts get far more responses than emails.

  • Use tap-to-review keychains or cards at the dock. They cost about $20, and guests tap their phones on the way off the boat. One operator's reviews exploded after they started using them.

  • Use your waiver data. When a group of 12 books, you usually only get the lead guest's contact. Your waiver system has everyone's. Ask your booking or waiver company for API or webhook access, push those contacts into your CRM, and send every guest a review request. It usually costs nothing to set up.

5. Raise rates when your market sells out. Most operators set prices and walk away. When every competitor is sold out on a Saturday, your last open seats are worth $10 to $15 more. Watch for sellouts and price your final spots to match. AI tools can already analyze your booking data. The next step, which Greg expects in 2027, is AI pushing the new rates straight into your reservation system.

Your OTA & Booking Site Checklist

  1. Pick 5 to 8 competitors closest to what you offer.

  2. Shop each one like a guest, all the way to checkout.

  3. Compare all-in prices, not listed prices.

  4. Plot everyone on a price and value map.

  5. Automate a weekly competitor report with AI.

  6. Pull the 5 levers before you cut your price.

Want Help Putting This to Work?

Saltwater Marketing helps charter captains and tour operators book more trips every day. Book a call and we'll walk through your pricing and listings together.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is an OTA?
An OTA, or online travel agency, is a marketplace where guests compare and book trips from many operators. Examples include Viator, TripAdvisor, GetYourGuide, Expedia, FishingBooker and TripShock.
Should I lower my price to get more bookings on OTAs?
Not as a first move. Run a pricing audit to see how you compare, then try dynamic weekday and weekend pricing, putting your value in your trip title, adding extras instead of discounts, and building recent reviews.
Should my OTA price match my website price?
Check each platform's rules. Some OTAs, like GetYourGuide, require price parity with your website, including fees. Prices that vary by channel also make it harder for guests to compare.
Should I show all-in pricing on my booking page?
Show what your market shows. Some states require all-in pricing, and some OTAs show it by default. If your competitors list pre-tax prices and you're the only one showing all-in, you'll look more expensive at a glance.
How many competitors should I include in a pricing audit?
5 to 8. Pick the operators closest to what you offer in trip type, price, group size and value. Leave out competitors racing to the bottom on price.
How can I compete with an operator who has thousands of reviews?
Focus on recent reviews. They now count more than total reviews, especially for AI tools. Automate post-trip review texts, use tap-to-review keychains at the dock, and use waiver data to ask every guest in a group, not just the one who booked.
How often should I check my competitors' prices?
Weekly. Set up a scheduled task in Claude or ChatGPT to pull your competitors' rates and email you a report, so you know when someone changes a price or adds a package.
Can AI help me price my charter or tour?
Yes. AI tools can pull competitor prices into a table, convert them to all-in prices, map where you stand and send you weekly updates. Use it to do the legwork, then make the pricing call yourself.

Ready to Grow?

We Can Make It Happen

SEE DEMO & PRICING